In Dining Reviews
In Dining Reviews
In Dining Reviews


Cafe One24 is gourmet organic dining oasis
The northeast corner of Brookfield, where it meets the northwest corner of Tosa, at 124th and Capitol, has become a shopping destination.
What it's never been is a dining destination. Sure, there are plenty of places to eat, with Joey's Seafood and Grill at the top of a hill built on the likes of Culver's, Chipotle and QDoba.
Sarah Dusseau, owner of Fit Food Trainer in Menomonee Falls, brings her passion for healthy eating to the neighborhood's first upscale dining restaurant, Cafe One24, which Dusseau opened this month at 3705 N. 124th St., across the hall from a Culver's and next door to a Chipotle.
The restaurant is an oasis of organic ingredients and gourmet dishes in an area dominated by fast food.
Entering the space, one is immediately taken aback that a low, almost strip mall-style building can be transformed into a space so warm and welcoming.
The east wall has been covered in Lannon stone and the south wall is an olive green. Like her food, Dusseau's restaurant space is clean, basic and inviting.
Although she plans to build up to serving lunch, at the moment Dusseau and her staff are focusing on dinner.
Her first menu is dominated by local ingredients from Wisconsin Grass Fed Beef Cooperative, Empire Fish, Sweetwater Organics, Cybros Sprouted Bakehouse and Growing Power.
On the menu – which clearly denotes vegetarian and gluten free options – expect to see apps like a Wisconsin cheese plate, sweet potato and wild mushroom flatbreads, crostini, mussels and more.
There is a range of sandwiches that run from $8 (portobello) to $12 (pulled chicken sliders), salads and soups from $7 (cafe salad, chili, soup of the day) to $14 (seared flank stead salad).
Entrees include seared scallops with mango and corn salsa and Nueske's bacon with Sweetwater Organics microgreens ($25), butternut squash ravioli with sage and goat cheese pan sauce ($13), a fresh fish of the day from nearby Empire Fish and others.
We visited on Cafe One24's first official weekend and were pleased to find nary a glitch in the system, from kitchen to table. We were greeted immediately and warmly and though the restaurant was already doing a brisk business we were seated right away.
A simple table, with a bright white dressing, a tealight and a single yellow rose in a white porcelain vase created an elegant and intimate atmosphere.
Our server was attentive, cheery and ready to offer recommendations.
We focused mainly on the seafood dishes in Dusseau's repertoire.
As an appetizer I had a dozen Prince Edward Island mussels ($11) in white wine with tarragon and fennel that was served with deliciously crisp toasted sprouted grain crostini. A blackened tilapia po boy ($11) followed. A sprouted grain hoagie roll was layered with asian slaw, a red pepper yogurt and a tender piece of sustainably farmed tilapia.
My companion choose the seared scallops ($23) and was extremely satisfied. Garnished with Sweetwater Organics microgreens, the scallops were accompanied by a sweet mango and grilled corn salsa and bits of Nueske's bacon that melted in the mouth and added a subtle smokiness to the dish.
The dessert menu was a little slim, but we ordered chocolate covered strawberries ($5.50) and finished our meal content and satisfied.
Cafe One24 also has an interesting beer and wine list and I tried my first Left Hand Milk Stout, which our server described as almost a chocolate milk beer. That was kind of true, but in a good way. The stout was milky thick with a nice tan head and had definite chocolate and coffee overtones.
Only open for dinner for now, Cafe One24 is open Tuesday through Saturday at 4:30 p.m. and closes at 10 p.m. except on Friday and Saturday when it's open until 11.
Cafe One24 is priced considerably higher than other eateries in its neighborhood but that's comparing apples and oranges. Cafe One24 is a good example of the adage that sometimes you get what you pay for.
Talkbacks
|
Post a comment / write a review. |
Facebook Comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Like Us
Follow Us















